Who will fix this 'eyesore'?



Weeds crack through the asphalt of the Blue Mountain Mall parking lot and appear to be the Mall's only signs of growth in its current fallen state of rubble and gutted structures. July 22, 2010


Instead of open to the public for shopping, "No Trespassing" signs send a warning instead of a welcome as unfinished structures lie vacant in the fenced in confines. July 22, 2010


The Blue Mountain Mall seems trapped in a web of uncertainty locked away behind chain link fences and "No Trespassing" signs. July 22, 2010


Portions of the Blue Mountain Mall remain torn and in a state of disrepair as the Mall awaits its ultimate fate. July 22, 2010


Traffic lights at one of the proposed new entrances to the Blue Mountain Mall off Poplar Street remain only dark silhouettes of lightless lights against an evening sunset. The need for the lights in anticipation of heavier traffic to the Mall disappeared as prospects for the Mall faded. July 22, 2010

A sale of the Blue Mountain Mall property in early July was canceled in the latest twist for the marooned retail development.

The commercial property was headed for auction on the courthouse steps after the lender for the $10.5 million acquisition foreclosed for failure to pay.

But less than 24 hours before the sale was set to take place, the owner of the mall property filed for emergency bankruptcy protection, a move that grants an "automatic stay" for the time being, attorneys say.

A small crowd of about 15 people gathered in front of the courthouse dissipated within seconds after what was expected to be a 9:30 a.m. auction start time. Instead, a representative of the lender announced the auction was reset to Aug. 13.

The change is another arc in an already complicated ownership saga that has confused even attorneys working on a resolution for the once-thriving commercial property.

"We have this thing out here that's a mess and there's nothing happening," said Walla Walla City Attorney Tim Donaldson.

In the weeks before the auction was canceled, Donaldson had initiated a second foreclosure motion after mall owners failed to pay more than $23,000 for assessments from road improvements linked to the mall property more than 20 years ago.

The amount is miniscule compared to the bill from the bank, contractors and others who've gone unpaid by the owners, Donaldson acknowledged. But the procedure is a step in pursuing some kind of resolution for the torn down, partially rebuilt and deserted property that Donaldson now describes as an "eyesore" and "embarassment."

The hard part, officials say, is tracking down who's responsible.

In the last two years, construction on a massive redevelopment of the mall between Rose and Polar Streets at Myra Road has stopped, contractors went unpaid and a previous foreclosure took place. Since a new limited liability company took possession more than a year ago, the property remains in a standstill with the remnants of a major demolition and partial new construction surrounding the lone businesses on the property: Sears, Shopko and Pizza Hut.

Several names have remained linked to the property despite the foreclosures and company changes. But getting any relief at the property and answers from the owners has become difficult, local officials said.

The development company that bought the land in 2008 was known as Blue Mountain Plaza LLC. That organization tore down the mall and began construction on new buildings at the property but defaulted on payments to contractors and lenders. They were foreclosed on over a year ago.

In February 2009 the mall was put up for auction. But the ownership firm that purchased the property, Walla Walla Holdings I LLC, apparently includes some of the same owners from Blue Mountain Plaza LLC. City officials have said Western Washington residents Winston and Jason Bontrager were both involved. Though Walla Walla Holdings I purchased the mall, an ownership change at the property took place in November of last year. The ownership company, according to the Walla Walla County Assessor's Office, is now Walla Walla Town Center LLC.

Walla Walla Town Center's manager, Jason Bontrager, signed the Chapter 11 bankruptcy petition, which was filed in King County.

Walla Walla Attorney James Hayner of Minnick Hayner Attorneys at Law said the bankruptcy filing is not an unusual move if the property owner believes there's some equity. Hayner has been retained by Sears and was at the auction as a representative of the retailer.

What is unusual, he said, is how intertwined the lenders and borrowers have become in the mall property.

The who's who of borrowers, lenders and owners has made it difficult to communicate about work on the property, as well as money owed. He and local officials, as well as retailers, continue to be hopeful the land will eventually be redeveloped into the thriving retail space it once was.

"(Sears officials) still have an operating store and still want to see some good come out of this," Hayner said.


Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.

Sign in to comment

Click here to sign in