Mubarak’s retrial delayed after judge recuses himself


Mubarak’s retrial delayed after judge recuses himself

CAIRO — A new trial for deposed Egyptian autocrat Hosni Mubarak ended just minutes after it opened Saturday morning when the presiding judge withdrew, igniting shouts of frustration in the court.

The recusal of Judge Mostafa Hassan Abdallah further delays a case that, for many Egyptians, has come to symbolize the elusiveness of justice in this tumultuous Arab nation more than two years after the revolution that many here had hoped would usher in a transparent democracy.

The 84-year-old Mubarak, his two sons and several former security officials face charges related to corruption and the killing of protesters during Egypt’s 18-day uprising in 2011.

A judge overturned Mubarak’s initial life sentence and ordered a retrial for all six defendants in January, after both the defense and the prosecution filed appeals.

Abdallah presided over another recent case related to violence allegedly perpetrated during the uprising. According to legal experts, it could take weeks for a new judge to be appointed in the Mubarak case.

The slow process of justice for Mubarak and other former government officials has become a long-standing source of anger in this country of 85 million — and a reason for deep suspicion of the courts.

“This whole institution of the judiciary is cast in shadows. It has taken a position against the people,” said Amir Salem, a lawyer for families of some of the people killed during the uprising.

Others have grown bored — or even sympathetic to Mubarak, who suffers from a host of health problems — as the court case slowly winds its way through a second year and many other former officials have been acquitted for lack of evidence.

“It’s a cold case. You and I have to follow it, but everyone else is tired of it,” said Saad Abdel Wahed, a retired head of the Giza Criminal Court.

Mubarak, despite his reputed frailty, appeared alert and confident in the defendants’ dock Saturday, waving several times to people in the court and conversing with his sons, who stood next to him. In the front row, Mubarak’s attorney, Farid el-Deeb, smoked a cigar.

“When I saw Mubarak today wearing his sunglasses and smiling, you kind of knew what was going to happen,” Abdel Wahed said. “I don’t like him, but we have this expression, ‘You only appreciate your mother when you meet you stepmother.’ The trial is just symbolic to people now. They have bigger issues to worry about.”


Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.

Sign in to comment

Click here to sign in