Resignation of School Board member not personnel matter


The chief executive of a government entity, such as a school district’s superintendent, answers to elected directors who sit on a school board. And the school board members answer to the public — the voters.

That’s the way it works pretty much everywhere in America.

Yet, when Walla Walla School Board member Max Carrera submitted his resignation, which is expected to be presented at tonight’s School Board meeting, school district officials would not release his name to the public.

Officials said the resignation was being treated as a personnel matter and therefore the district would not release the identity of the resigning School Board member until tonight’s meeting.

School officials are wrong. When a publicly elected Board member sends in a letter of resignation it is a public matter. We checked with Washington state Assistant Attorney General for Government Accountability Timothy D. Ford and he concurred.

But even if it were a personnel matter — it would then be between the employee (Board member) and the boss (voters). It is still a public matter.

Thankfully, the dispute over the release of the name quickly became moot when Carrera returned the Sunday phone call of U-B reporter Maria P. Gonzalez on Monday and told her he was resigning. This matter did not need to become an open-records issue.

Carrera told Gonzalez he was stepping down and why. (This occurred after Monday’s edition was printed.)

On Monday, just after noon, Carrera said he was leaving the School Board to focus his time and attention on raising his teenage son and young daughter as a single dad. Carrera said he is also helping care for his mother, whose health is declining.

It’s a very understandable reason.

Why the secrecy?

It’s still unclear who made the decision to treat this as a personnel matter and why.

We hope it was a mistake made in understanding the law regarding when information can be withheld from the public.

The next time a similar situation involving elected School Board members arises, we would hope the people would be properly informed in a timely manner as to the intent of their elected School Board members.


Iopine 2 years, 6 months ago

And then the bewildered tone of the school district - WHAT - you distrust us? Oh sure we'll put $70 million in the hands of who and for what? It is very clever if the voters let them get away with it.


eastoregonian 2 years, 6 months ago

Transparency is the window for good government. The school district was absolutely wrong in its misguided attempt to keep this a secret. An apology is in order and hopefully they will not repeat this type of behavior. Thanks to the U-B for pointing out the district's error.


ImJustSayin 2 years, 6 months ago

The UB needs to learn that public entities are different from private entities when it comes to privacy issues related to personnel. When public entities are sued left and right these days, it's understandable to want to err on the side of caution.


dloudermilk 2 years, 6 months ago

Big Deal, the guy is resigning for personel reasons. Thanks to Max for your service to our community. And the UB scooped it 8 hours before it was going to be announced. I could have waited for that BIG bit of news. I do agree the school district needs to be transparent on how they are spending the money.


Sign in to comment

Click here to sign in